Netflix’s $72 Billion Gamble on Warner Bros Might Be Dead on Arrival

Published on December 13, 2025 by Mason Carter

On the morning of Dec. 5, Hollywood awoke to news that played like someone had shuffled the deck and dealt an entirely new game. Netflix would like to purchase Warner Bros for $72 billion. Netflix wants to buy Warner Bros. for $72 billion. That’s billions with a B. Batman, Harry Potter, Game of Thrones, and the entire HBO catalogue. All of it is potentially under Netflix’s control.

The Netflix Warner Bros deal would forge a streaming monster unlike anything we’ve seen before. We’re referring here to 300 million Netflix subscribers and HBO Max’s current base of 128 million users. Nearly half a billion people are watching content controlled by one company. That’s not just big. That’s “Hey government, maybe take a look at this” big.

Why This Happened

Warner Bros Discovery was drowning in debt. HBO Max had 128 million subscribers but couldn’t compete with Netflix’s 300 million. Growth stalled. The company put itself up for sale in October.

Paramount looked like the obvious buyer. They wanted everything, even the cable channels nobody watches anymore. They had connections to Trump through Larry Ellison, Oracle’s founder and dad of Paramount’s CEO David Ellison.

Then Netflix came in hot with two proposals that week. Ted Sarandos admitted on a call with analysts Friday morning, “I know some of you are surprised that we’re making this acquisition.”

No kidding, Ted. Netflix spent years refusing to buy anything, insisting they’d build everything themselves. Now they’re spending more than most countries’ GDP.

What Netflix Actually Gets

Warner Bros film and TV studios. HBO Max. HBO itself. Gaming business. “The Sopranos,” “Game of Thrones,” “Friends,” and the entire DC Universe. Cultural touchstones people actually pay to watch.

The deal is $23.25 cash and $4.50 Netflix stock per Warner Bros Discovery share. Total value hits $82.7 billion with debt. Netflix lined up $59 billion in bank financing to pull this purchase off.

Why Netflix’s Warner Bros Deal Could Collapse Fast!
Source by gettyimages

Warner’s splitting first. Netflix gets the good stuff. Discovery Global gets CNN, TNT, TBS, and the cable networks. That split happens in summer 2026.

Netflix Warner Bros Antitrust Issues Are Already Killing It

This is where everything falls apart.

The merger would give Netflix roughly 30% to 43% of the streaming market. Anything above 30% makes regulators nervous. Trump himself said Sunday, “It is a big market share. It could be a problem.”

When Trump’s worried about market concentration, you know it’s bad.

Senator Mike Lee, a Republican from Utah who chairs the Senate antitrust committee, said the deal “should send alarm to antitrust enforcers around the world.” He’s planning hearings.

Elizabeth Warren called it “an anti-monopoly nightmare.” When Warren and Lee agree something’s wrong, it’s probably not happening.

The Political Mess Gets Worse

By choosing Netflix, Warner Bros. rejected Paramount. That means they rejected Larry Ellison, the world’s second-richest man and a Trump buddy.

Ellison’s son runs Paramount. They thought this was done. Trump praised Paramount’s acquisition in August. Now Netflix steals it from them.

Paramount’s lawyers sent Warner a 4,000-word letter warning that Netflix’s bid faces “grave uncertainty and significant opposition by competition law enforcement agencies.” Then on Monday, Paramount launched a hostile tender offer at $30 per share, all cash. Offer expires January 8th.

If Paramount buys enough shares before Warner’s shareholders vote on the Netflix deal, the Netflix merger dies.

So now it’s a bidding war with political pressure and regulatory nightmares all happening at once.

Netflix Warner Bros. and Paramount Fighting While Everything Burns

Netflix needs shareholder approval. That requires proxy statements, SEC filings, and a vote that takes months. Paramount’s tender offer happens way before that vote.

Netflix’s stock dropped 2% after announcing the deal. Warner’s stock gained 2%. Investors don’t think this closes.

Netflix committed to a $5.8 billion breakup fee if regulators kill it or it falls apart. One of the biggest breakup fees ever. Shows either confidence or desperation.

Netflix argues more than 75% of HBO Max subscribers already have Netflix anyway, making them complementary, not competitive. They’ll say combining reduces costs and lowers consumer prices.

Why Netflix’s Warner Bros Deal Could Collapse Fast!
Source by gettyimages

Herbert Hovenkamp, antitrust law professor at the University of Pennsylvania, said, “It looks challengeable. This is a fairly concentrated market where you get concerned about higher prices.”

Netflix Warner Bros HBO Combo Nobody Trusts

Netflix getting HBO changes everything. HBO’s been the gold standard for prestige TV for decades. Warner Bros. movies are cultural institutions. Putting all that under Netflix control worries people beyond just antitrust.

Netflix promised to maintain Warner Bros’ theatrical releases through 2029. Theatre owners don’t believe them. Netflix hates theatrical releases. They want everything straight to streaming.

Hollywood unions fear this makes job losses worse. Fewer writers, shorter seasons, less work for everyone.

What Happens Next

Best case? The deal closes in the third quarter of 2026. Regulators approve it, maybe with conditions. Paramount goes away mad.

Worst case? DOJ blocks it entirely. Netflix pays that $5.8 billion breakup fee. Paramount takes Warner instead.

Prediction markets on Polymarket showed just a 23% chance of Netflix closing this by the end of 2026. Down from 60% before Trump’s comments. Smart money says it’s dead.

Justice Department reviews can take months to over a year. Trump’s personally involved now. Senators from both parties oppose it. Paramount’s making a competing offer. This isn’t a normal merger review anymore. This is political theater with $72 billion on the line.

Senators Bernie Sanders and Richard Blumenthal wrote to the DOJ, worried about Trump’s relationship with Ellison creating “a cesspool of political favouritism and corruption.” Whether that’s true or just politics, it shows how messy this got.

The Reality Check

Streaming hit a wall. Growth stopped. Prices went up. Every company is losing money competing with Netflix. Warner Bros. Discovery couldn’t make it alone. Neither could Paramount.

Hollywood knows consolidation has to happen. The question isn’t whether companies merge. The question is how much is too much.

Netflix argues that buying Warner creates opportunities. More content, wider audiences, and better funding for productions. Fair point. Warner’s IP becomes shows and movies that Warner couldn’t afford alone.

But regulators have to believe that. Right now, with the Netflix Warner Bros. deal facing opposition from Trump, both parties, competitors, and unions, nobody believes it.

Ted Sarandos bet $72 billion that Netflix could pull this off. Maybe they can. Maybe Trump changes his mind. Maybe DOJ approves with conditions. Maybe Paramount’s hostile offer fails.

Or maybe this whole thing collapses and becomes a case study in what happens when you try buying half of Hollywood while the president’s watching.

We’ll know in 18 months. Assuming it lasts that long.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *